Hospital Blood Tests in Texas DWI Cases: Specimens, Methods and Evidence
Updated: Oct 27
AI-generated illustration; the tubes are not actual patient specimens or case evidence.
Start with the specimen and the units
When a hospital alcohol result becomes part of a DWI investigation, identify the actual specimen, method, units and collection time before comparing it with another test. Do not assume every hospital uses the same specimen or that a clinical result is automatically unreliable.
Serum or plasma and whole blood differ in composition. Their alcohol concentrations can differ for that reason even when each measurement is analytically sound. Calling the higher value artificially inflated can confuse a specimen difference with a testing error.
Why a universal percentage shortcut is inadequate
Published research on clinical and forensic comparisons supports careful interpretation of specimen differences. It does not justify applying one fixed percentage to every patient or declaring someone sober from an adjusted number alone. The actual records and the scientific basis for an estimate matter.
Also check the units. Results expressed in milligrams per deciliter and grams per deciliter cannot be compared as if the printed numerals meant the same thing. A unit conversion and a serum-to-whole-blood interpretation are different operations.
Compare purpose, method and timing
Hospital testing guides clinical care; forensic testing addresses a different use. Determine the method actually used rather than assigning it from the laboratory’s name. Request relevant analytical information where needed to assess a comparison.
Collection time and analysis time are separate facts. Two samples taken at different times may differ for reasons other than specimen type. The records must support any explanation; neither a time gap nor a method label proves a particular defense.
Handling concerns require evidence
Review available collection, identification, storage and testing records. If contamination or post-collection alcohol formation is proposed, identify the conditions and evidence supporting that explanation. A missing detail in one record does not automatically establish contamination.
Do not assume alcohol skin preparation necessarily contaminated a sample or that a hospital cannot maintain adequate records. A credible challenge identifies a specific supported concern, explains its possible significance and acknowledges what remains unknown.
Obtaining a record and admitting a result are separate issues
Whether medical records were lawfully obtained and whether a result is admissible are legal questions that depend on the process, foundation, objections and facts. Neither medical confidentiality nor a prosecutor’s possession of a chart decides every issue.
A useful consultation starts with the actual hospital report and dates, any police testing records, the charging paperwork and the questions the records raise. Qualified scientific review may help determine whether the proposed comparison is appropriate.
Before comparing two alcohol results
Review area | What to check | What not to assume |
Specimen | Whole blood, serum or plasma | A specimen difference is not automatically a testing error |
Units | The reporting scale for each result | Different printed numbers cannot be compared without checking units |
Method | The analytical process actually used | A laboratory name alone does not establish its method |
Timing and handling | Collection times and available identification and storage records | A time gap or missing detail does not itself prove contamination |
What to bring
The original hospital report and relevant records already available
Any police or forensic test report you have
Available collection and analysis dates and times
Specimen type, units and method as printed in the records
Charging documents and notices identifying the allegation
Questions about missing records and whether scientific review would help
Bring what you have and ask which additional records are needed. Keep case details for your lawyer rather than posting them publicly.
Questions about your Houston DWI case?
To discuss representation, call Ruben Restrepo at 713-714-7330 or contact the office. Learn more about our Houston DWI practice. Please do not post details of your case in public comments.
Sources and review
Reviewed October 19, 2026. General information; individual facts, notices and orders matter.
Jones and Tilson — Ethanol distribution between whole blood, plasma and serum — Journal of Forensic Sciences, January 2023; published online November 1, 2022. Specimen composition and interpretation; abstract reviewed.
Comparison of hospital enzymatic serum results with forensic whole-blood gas chromatography — Original patient-sample comparison, 2007; cautions against an unqualified universal conversion factor. Abstract reviewed; it does not establish a legal outcome.



